Back to the list


The Rise and Fall of Militant Skepticism
By Deepak Chopra, M.D., FACP

Skepticism has gotten itself into a pickle - perhaps something a lot more serious than a pickle - that is undermining its good name. The credibility of Wikipedia may be at stake (see below). We live in a skeptical age, because the cornerstone of science, "Everything must be verified," is a skeptical position. When a researcher claims to have accomplished something remarkable, such as cold fusion, his experiment must be replicated before it will be believed. The need to verify, to lay out credible facts, has become second nature, and not just for scientists.

Facts, data, information, research findings, statistics - these are woven into every aspect of our lives. Which means that skepticism is woven in, too. Hence its good name. Without accurate polls, politicians would be lost (consult Mitt Romney, who believed in skewed polls all the way to election night). But there is no reason for skepticism to become a militant crusade. Facts are facts, as the saying goes, and when a political ideology like Fascism identified Einstein as someone who conducted "Jewish science" (a term coined by the Nazis), such a label is not simply abhorrent - it misconstrues what science actually is, a universal enterprise that has no place for personal, religious, or political prejudice.

The rise of militant skepticism clouded the picture, however, beginning with its popular attack on religion. The aim of Richard Dawkins, as stated in his best seller, The God Delusion, was to subject "the God hypothesis" to scientific scrutiny, the way one would subject anti-matter or black holes to scrutiny. In fact he did no such thing with God, for the scientific method requires experiments that can be replicated and facts that can be verified. Dawkins offered no experiments to prove or disprove the existence of God. What he actually did was to subject religion to a barrage of scorn and ridicule, attacking it on the rational improbability - as he sees it - that a deity could possibly exist.

The commercial success of his book wasn't hard to explain. Long ago Darwin's theory of evolution had toppled the creation story found in the Book of Genesis, and through a domino effect the toppling continued. By the time The God Delusion appeared in 2006, organized religion was still in decline, and millions of readers were happy to seize on a "scientific" book that relieved them of any guilt over not going to church or temple. Atheism was held out by Dawkins as the only enlightened position one could take on the God question. He anticipated that readers would flock to become atheists with himself in the lead, a social movement that never, in fact, materialized. Polls continue to show that well over 80% of people believe in God, and something like 1 in 8 atheists go to church, while no massive surge in unbelief has occurred.

The God Delusion, aided by a handful of other best sellers attacking religion in the same vein, did have one decisive effect, however. Science became yoked to the tools of rhetoric and demagoguery, going so far as to lose any trace of objectivity. These tools, once shunned by science, were useful to Dawkins, given that he had no actual scientific proof that God doesn't exist. Hostile reviewers cried foul, but the complaints came from a mixed lot of religious fundamentalists, philosophers, and theologians who hardly presented a united front. Among the most educated and the least educated groups, Dawkins had no credibility. But the job had been done. It was now "scientific" for militant skepticism to practice forms of intellectual dishonesty that have only proliferated.

Thanks to the Internet, skepticism can spread with the speed of light, carrying in its wake all forms of unfairness and bad faith. A distressing example has been occurring at Wikipedia, where a band of committed skeptics have focused their efforts to discredit anyone whom they judge an enemy. The problem has been slow to gain traction in the public arena, because Wikipedia has constructed an elaborate set of rules to minimize editorial bias. Ironically, the skeptics have turned these rules, which run to hundreds of pages, to their advantage. They have become so skilled at thwarting anyone who disagrees with their point of view that a small swarm of skeptical editors is capable of outnumbering, bullying, and even banning all those who oppose them.

You can see the results at the Wikipedia entry for Rupert Sheldrake, the British biologist who has served as a lightning rod for militant skeptics for several decades. Intelligent, highly trained, an impeccable thinker, and a true advocate for experimentation and validation, Sheldrake had the temerity to be skeptical about the everyday way that science is conducted. He made his first splash by questioning the accepted assumptions of Darwinian evolution, and most recently he published a cogent, well-received book about the hidden weaknesses in the scientific method, titled Science Set Free. His avowed aim is to expand science beyond its conventional boundaries in the hope that a new path to discovery can be opened up.

But you'd never know it from Sheldrake's Wikipedia entry, which is largely derogatory and even defamatory, thanks to a concerted attack by a stubborn band of militant skeptics. Since I am close to Sheldrake personally and have Wikipedia woes of my own, it's not fair for me to offer accusations over the extent to which Wikipedia is under attack. But the skeptics have been caught in the act, which is the pickle they find themselves in, as I mentioned at the outset of this post.

You can read a detailed account in a series of online posts written by Craig Weiler at his blog The Weiler Psi. Confronting the militant pests at Wikipedia resembles taking hold of a tar baby, as Weiler relates in his most recent post, pointedly entitled "Wikipedia: The Only Way to Win Is Not to Play." The unsavory fact is that skeptics have figured out how to game Wikipedia's attempts to provide fairness, and we are all the loser for it.

Dawkins and the militant skeptics are symptoms of a deeper problem that turns out to have fascinating implications. Noisy as they are, these hostile crusaders have had no impact on the everyday activity of doing science or keeping faith. But that is about to change. The deep question of what is real is one that contemporary science can no longer avoid. How this is leading to the decline of skepticism makes for an intriguing mystery story, which will be discussed in the next post.

(To be cont.)
Deepak Chopra, MD is the author of more than 75 books with twenty-one New York Times bestsellers. Coming soon What Are You Hungry For? (Harmony, November 12, 2013)

Write Your Comment


purchase cheapest Disulfiram no rx required in UK [/b]; cheap price for Disulfiram no prior script overnight ; cheap price Disulfiram without dr prescription in UK ; buy Disulfiram cash on delivery in Canada ; cheapest price Disulfiram in New Orleans, La.


[i]Disulfiram in Aberdeen [/i]
[url=]purchase cheapest Allergy medicines no prior prescription in Australia | buy Allergy medicines[/url]
Disulfiram in Omaha
[url=]want to buy Leukeran prescriptions online | buy safety cheap Leukeran[/url]
Disulfiram in Bangor
[url=]where can i purchase Gestanin in Seattle , Wash. | best price Gestanin[/url]
Disulfiram in Raleigh
[url=]cheap price Ponstel in Portland , Ore. | order at low price Ponstel[/url]
Disulfiram in Salisbury
Disulfiram cheap cod no rx USA
[url=]buy cheap online Tacrolimus with no prescriptions in Canada | buy cheap Tacrolimus[/url]
Disulfiram online USA in Leeds
[url=]cheap Hair Loss medicines available in UK,Ireland | safe order Hair Loss medicines[/url]
Cheap Disulfiram overnight no script mastercard accepted
[url=]buy Sulfasalazine non prescription | best price Sulfasalazine[/url]
Low Prices Disulfiram in Cheyenne
[url=]online pharmacy Voltarol no script next day delivery in Australia | price Voltarol[/url]
Order Online Generic Disulfiram
[url=]cheap price for Metoprolol in New Orleans, La. | where to buy Metoprolol[/url]
Fda Approved Disulfiram from canadian pharmacy no prescription
[url=]purchase online Tadapox overnight without prescription in Canada | buy safety cheap Tadapox[/url]
Cost For Disulfiram no prescription drugstore
[url=]cheapest place to order Flonase Nasal Spray no prescription | buying online cheapest Flonase Nasal Spray[/url]
Purchase Disulfiram no prescription overnight shipping
[url=]how to order Propranolol without doctor prescription in UK | cheapest place to order Propranolol[/url]
Buy At Low Price Disulfiramin Bangor
[url=]buy safety cheap Isosorbide mononitrate without rx in Australia | wholesale Isosorbide mononitrate[/url]
Disulfiram shipped with no prescription USA
[url=]cheapest place to order Arcoxia c.o.d. without rx | buying online cheapest Arcoxia[/url]
Purchase Cheapest Disulfiramin Detroit
[url=,]ordering online Anacin without rx in Canada | discount price Anacin[/url]
Buy Generic Disulfiram cash on delivery
[url=]where to buy Frumil c.o.d. without rx | licensed pharmacy Frumil[/url]
Orders Disulfiram overnight delivery without a rx
[url=]fda approved Lamisil non prescription | online pharmacy Lamisil[/url]
Get Low Cost Disulfiram in Ireland
[url=]order cheap online Combivent in Fort Worth , Tex. | online pharmacy Combivent[/url]
Discount Pharmacy Disulfiram online in
[url=]buy cheapest Retin-A in San Francisco , Calif. | low price Retin-A[/url]
Purchase Best Price Disulfiramin Inverness
Buy Cheap Generic Disulfiram quick delivery no prescription
[url=]order LIV.52 drops next day no prescription needed | discount price LIV.52 drops[/url]
I Want With Discount Disulfiram privately no rx
[url=]buying cheap Beloc in El Paso, Tex. | ordering online Beloc[/url]
Legitimate Places To Buy Disulfiram no prescription united states
[url=]cheap Erythromycin in San Jose, Calif. | purchase cheap online Erythromycin[/url]
Disulfiram next day delivery
[url=]cheapest price Glipizide no prescription united states | order online cheap Glipizide[/url]
Where Can I Buy Generic Disulfiram in Colorado Springs
[url=]fda approved Alfacalcidol no script needed in Australia | purchase cheap online Alfacalcidol[/url]
Where To Purchase Disulfiramin San Antonio, Tex.
[url=]purchase cheapest Trazodone no rx required | purchase cheap online Trazodone[/url]
Order Generic Disulfiram in Nottingham
[url=]online pharmacy Serophene in Australia no prescription needed | fda approved Serophene[/url]
How To Order Disulfiram without perscription or membership
[url=]cheapest price Nolvadex no prescriptions needed in USA | buy online Nolvadex[/url]
Mail Order Discounts On Disulfiram in Portugal
[url=]purchase cheapest Synthroid overnight delivery no rx | licensed pharmacy Synthroid[/url]
Get Low Cost Disulfiram in Newport
[url=]cheap price for Dydrogesterone from a Australia pharmacy without a prescription | buy cheap Dydrogesterone[/url]
Buy Online Disulfiram in Bangor
[url=]buying online cheapest SleepWell no prescription in Australia | cheapest prices SleepWell[/url]
Cheap Price For Generic Disulfiram in Jacksonville
[url=]how i can buy Lopressor without rx in UK | buying cheap Lopressor[/url]
Cheap Disulfiram in China
[url=]buy cheapest Medroxyprogesterone no prescription | order safety Medroxyprogesterone[/url]
Online Pharmacy Disulfiram in Londonderry
[url=]order Effexor in Memphis, Tenn. | where to purchase Effexor[/url]
Buy Generic Disulfiram in Honolulu
Rodneyzoor - January 19, 2016
licensed pharmacy Tadora without prescription in UK [/b]; cheapest Tadora credit card no prescription ; orders Tadora no prescriptions needed in USA ; cheapest Tadora cash on delivery in Australia ; where to buy Tadora overnight without prescription in USA


[i]Tadora in Kansas City [/i]
[url=]low prices Prandin no prescription united states | order online cheap Prandin[/url]
Tadora in India
[url=]order Clonidine without prescription in USA | ordering online Clonidine[/url]
Tadora in St Albans
[url=]ordering cheap Desmopressin c.o.d. saturday delivery | buy online Desmopressin[/url]
Tadora in Quebec
[url=]ordering cheap Nizoral c.o.d overnight no rx | order online cheap Nizoral[/url]
Tadora in Inverness
Tadora shipped with no prescription USA
[url=]ordering online Alfuzosin no prescription overnight in Australia | order online cheap Alfuzosin[/url]
Tadora online legally in London
[url=]buy online Geriforte in Baltimore, Md. | purchase cheap online Geriforte[/url]
Where To Order Tadora no prescriptions needed USA
[url=]cheapest price Ditropan Xl non prescription in Australia | discount price Ditropan Xl[/url]
Where Can I Purchase Tadora in Oxford
[url=]where can i purchase Terbinafine in El Paso, Tex. | online pharmacy Terbinafine[/url]
Where Can I Purchase Tadora
[url=]want to buy Ropinirole c.o.d. no rx | safe order Ropinirole[/url]
Where Can I Purchase Tadora online lowest prices
[url=]order cheap Acarbose no rx required | lowest prices Acarbose[/url]
Where To Purchase Tadora no prescriptions needed
[url=]for sale Eye drop medicines no prior script overnight | where can i buy Eye drop medicines[/url]
Order Cheap Generic Tadora prescription from doctors online
[url=]buy cheapest Topamax no prescription overnight | safe order Topamax[/url]
Purchase Generic Tadorain West Virginia
[url=]licensed pharmacy Clozapine no prescription in Australia | buy online Clozapine[/url]
Tadora overnight fedex
[url=]order online Meclizine in Memphis, Tenn. | discount Meclizine[/url]
Legitimate Places To Buy Tadorain Jackson
[url=]ordering online Rosuvastatin from a Australia pharmacy without a prescription | where can i buy Rosuvastatin[/url]
Best Price For Generic Tadora overnight no prescription USA
[url=]purchase Mebeverine no rx required in USA | online pharmacy Mebeverine[/url]
How To Purchase Tadora drug without prescription
[url=]order at low price Arthritis medicines without doctor prescription in Canada | best place to buy Arthritis medicines[/url]
Orders Tadora in Coventry
[url=]where can i buy Cyproheptadine no prescription required in USA | buy Cyproheptadine[/url]
Purchase Generic Tadora no perscription overnight
[url=]licensed pharmacy Acarbose in Tulsa, Okla. | order cheap online Acarbose[/url]
Buy Legitimate Tadorain Exeter
Order Cheap Generic Tadora money order
[url=]for sale Glucotrol in Miami, Fla. | purchase online Glucotrol[/url]
Buy Online Cheap Tadora next day no prescription
[url=]licensed pharmacy Lioresal in Kansas City, Mo. | safe order Lioresal[/url]
Purchase Cheapest Generic Tadora no prior prescription USA
[url=]order online cheap LIV.52 drops pharmacy without a prescription | cheapest price LIV.52 drops[/url]
Tadora online saturday delivery
[url=]buy cheapest Aygestin no prescriptions needed in UK | where to order Aygestin[/url]
Buy Cheap Online Tadora in Glasgow
[url=]buy safety cheap Zantac no rx required in USA | buy cheap Zantac[/url]
Buy Legitimate Tadorain Oakland, Calif.
[url=]cheap price Zetia in Columbus, Ohio | order cheapest Zetia[/url]
Where Can I Buy Tadora in Gloucester
[url=]mail order Hyzaar c.o.d. no rx | mail order Hyzaar[/url]
Can I Purchase Generic Tadora drug without prescription
[url=]best place to buy Chlorogen 800 overnight delivery without a rx | where can i buy Chlorogen 800[/url]
Tablets Tadora in France
[url=,-colo-how-i-can-buy-chloroquine.html#28347]low prices Chloroquine in Denver , Colo. | how i can buy Chloroquine[/url]
Where Can I Buy Generic Tadora in Los Angeles
[url=]want to buy Dutasteride in Fresno, Calif. | online pharmacy Dutasteride[/url]
Buy Online Cheap Tadora in Preston
[url=]buy cheap online Erectalis no rx required in UK | order at low price Erectalis[/url]
Buy Cheap Tadora in Bradford
[url=]how to purchase Sumatriptan in Charlotte, N.C. | discount Sumatriptan[/url]
Purchase Generic Tadora in Colorado
[url=]mail order Altace in Canada no prescription | where to order Altace[/url]
Buy Cheap Generic Tadora in UK
[url=]best place to buy Raloxifene without doctor prescription in UK | cheap price Raloxifene[/url]
Cheapest Generic Tadora in Phoenix
Rodneyzoor - January 19, 2016
where to buy Metoclopramide delivery no prescription
19931 Political views differ on average across nations re Listen Orlando isnt that bad!

[i][u]GO to PHARMACY >>>>> [/u][/i]

Discount Drugs without doctor prescription USA
[url=]buy cheap Progestogen c.o.d. saturday delivery | where to buy Progestogen[/url]
Cheap Price prescription from doctors online
[url=]buying cheap Nevirapine no script needed in USA | buy cheap Nevirapine[/url]
Can I Purchase Generic without dr prescription
[url=]buying online cheapest Orlistat in Tucson, Ariz. | low price Orlistat[/url]
Best Price no script next day delivery USA
[url=]discount price Amlodipine no prescription quick delivery | cheap price Amlodipine[/url]
Order Cheap Generic without a perscription shipped overnight
[url=]purchase cheap online Furazolidone no prescriptions needed in USA | mail order Furazolidone[/url]
Cheap Pharmacy Hair Loss Cream from u.s. pharmacy
[url=]price Ilosone in Dallas, Tex. | buy discount Ilosone[/url]
Get Approved Hair Loss Cream without prescription overnight shipping
[url=]lowest prices Differin cheap c.o.d. no rx | cheapest Differin[/url]
Ordering Hair Loss Cream free consultation USA
[url=]want to buy Revatio free prescription drug in Canada | low price Revatio[/url]
Where To Buy Hair Loss Cream overnight cheap USA
[url=]buy cheap online Arimidex in Indianapolis, Ind. | purchase cheapest Arimidex[/url]
Cheapest Generic Hair Loss Cream nextday shipping USA
[url=]order at low price Verapamil no prescription next day delivery in USA | purchase Verapamil[/url]
Mail Order Hair Loss Cream online cheap no rx
[url=]purchase Carafate in Cleveland, Ohio | online pharmacy Carafate[/url]
Order Easy Hair Loss Cream medication without rx
[url=]order Spironolactone no rx required | ordering online Spironolactone[/url]
I Want With Discount Hair Loss Cream free prescription drug USA
[url=]where to buy Bupropion without rx in Canada | purchase online Bupropion[/url]
Purchase Best Price Hair Loss Cream overnight delivery cod USA
[url=]purchase online Tadapox in Cleveland, Ohio | mail order Tadapox[/url]
Order Online Generic Hair Loss Cream online at low cost
[url=]how i can buy Alfuzosin no prescription in Canada | purchase cheapest Alfuzosin[/url]
Do You Know How I Can Buy Hair Loss Cream c.o.d overnight no rx
[url=]order online cheap Nateglinide in Nashville-Davidson, Tenn.1 | how to purchase Nateglinide[/url]
Buy Cheap Generic Hair Loss Cream buy cod
[url=]price Nolvadex from a USA pharmacy without a prescription | how i can buy Nolvadex[/url]
Purchase Hair Loss Cream overnight no prescription USA
[url=]how to order Ezetimibe next day no prescription in Australia | order Ezetimibe[/url]
Buy Safety Hair Loss Cream fedex without rx
[url=]low cost Norvasc no script next day delivery in Australia | fda approved Norvasc[/url]
Fda Approved Hair Loss Cream overnight shipping
[url=]where can i buy Venlafaxine no prescription quick delivery | purchase cheap online Venlafaxine[/url]
Licensed Pharmacy To Buy Hair Loss Cream online with visa
StephenDag - January 19, 2016
Hi there! I could have sworn I've been to this blog before but after checking through some of the post I realized it's new to me. Nonetheless, I'm definitely happy I found it and I'll be bookmarking and checking back frequently! cefbggddefkg
Johng940200 - November 9, 2015
There are many reasons why you can rest assured that using natural cosmetics over chemical ones is the right decision for you, from saving money, the environment and benefiting your long term health.How? Ever shopped for wholesale cosmetics? It is probably uncommon to buy wholesale women's cosmetics compared to buying wholesale clothing and accessories. [url=]moncler outlet online[/url] However, as technologies designed, waterresistant and windproof components within the jacket can dress in in raining and wind days.Perhaps the apparent dedication in all organizations could be reframed as selfinterest. [url=]piumini moncler[/url] While we value freedom of speech, we also wish to protect our visitors from exposure to inflammatory content.This liner will keep the absorbent clay/brick inside dry, tuck pointing and sealing will keep the outside dry.
odomatTut - September 25, 2015

Clenství in the medial temporal lobe play a major role in the brain's ability to form memories. Researchers studied patients with epilepsy who'd had electrodes implanted to identify seizure focus for surgical treatment in order to measure episodic memory formation at the cellular level. ( Neuron )
viagra prix de dressage handbags
[url=]viagra prix suisse[/url]
prix viagra maroc pharmacie
Veuillez compléter vos informations de compte pour vous inscrire en tant que référent thématique.
Combien gagnez-vous par an?
[url=]commander viagra en france[/url]
Un consommateur de la région de Québec a porté plainte au MAPAQ
Nous sommes heureux que vous voulez nous donner vos commentaires. S'il vous plaît noter les règles suivantes à l'avance: La rédaction se réserve le droit de ne pas publier des commentaires. Ceci s'applique en général, mais surtout pour les propos diffamatoires, racistes, hors de propos, hors-sujet des commentaires, ou ceux en langues étrangères ou dialecte. Commentaires des noms de fantaisie, ou avec des noms manifestement fausses ne sont pas publiés non plus. Plus les décisions de la rédaction n'est ni responsable déposée, ni en dehors de la correspondance. Renseignements téléphoniques ne seront pas fournis. L'éditeur se réserve le droit également à réduire les commentaires des lecteurs. S'il vous plaît noter que votre commentaire aussi sur Google et autres moteurs de recherche peuvent être trouvés et que les éditeurs ne peuvent rien et est de supprimer un commentaire une fois émis dans l'index des moteurs de recherche.

[url=]acheter viagra en ligne danger[/url]
[url=]viagra naturel plante[/url]
[url=]viagra sans ordonnance en pharmacie jean[/url]
Howardgah - July 13, 2015
Unfortunately, the scientific method is forever doomed, by definition, any time it is used as a vehicle to prove a negative. In the instance of \"god\" no potential investigative tool exists. That only leaves critical thinking. Truly critical thinking can come to only one conclusion on on the existence of is a rational impossibility.\n\nDawkins methodology to come to that conclusion is flawed in that he tries to do it utilizing scientific methodology, exposing his own biases. The burden of proof on the subject doesn`t fall on the atheist but upon the believer. Dawkins, and by extension Wiki, have fallen into the honey trap of attempting to prove the unprovable. It doesn`t mean their conclusions are wrong but exposes the folly of using a shotgun to attack a will o` the wisp.
montanaric - May 1, 2014
Militant skeptics undermined allready many websites and webtools like Wikipedia, WebOfTrust, AmazonBook-review, GoogleMaps and more. Don`t loose any time to discuss with them. They lie, use manipulated evidence and put your words into another context to make you a criminal. The best is to ignore them. They are well organised in international networks using RSS-feeds and other tools. If you start to correct their lies, they attack you with shitstorms from anonymous servers. Just look at all the learning-videos on and you know, what`s going on and who is the source. We saved all these videos on separate tapes (evidence for future court cases). In other words: Militant skeptics have allready shouffled their own graves. A whole bunch of other skeptics will join them, because they missed to distance themselfes from the militant web-criminals, instead they supported these internet-terrorists with comments and/or linked to their slanderous websites.
skeptexposer - November 25, 2013